Independent Randall's Island hotels

"Neighborhood issue made literal brown water spew from the sink and shower out last night. Absolutely disgusting. But overall the stay was luxury leaning, as far as amenities but the walls are VERY thin and made sleeping in pretty hard. This is the kind of hotel you sleep and then get up and go. Not staycation vibes but luckily I was up and out most days. Would stay again, 6/10 chance. Stay was overall a 7."

"We loved the SoHo Grand. The room was comfortable, the staff were very friendly and helpful and the location is excellent. We will definitely be back!"

"The only issue was the loud music one night. We were above some kind of bar/lounge. At 12:30am i called reception. The staff member was rude to me while i was super calm with my inquiry about the loud music "

"Beautiful room"

"Small space so good for a solo trip."

"The property itself was a bit outdated. The room was a bit cluttered and small but that's to be expected in NYC. The outlets were in terrible shape and require updating but otherwise it was walkable to Times Square and very convenient for the meetings I had."

"Thank you"

"Pleasant stay during January—conveniently located and the staff was super helpful. Thanks!"