I spent a long weekend at the Creamsicle Cottage and I highly recommend it. It is the perfect size, extremely clean, and well maintained. Perfect for 1 or 2 couples, the bedrooms are large and each has it's own bathroom. Nice front porch and backyard for grilling. And, perfect for dogs too.
The location is great, walkable to see the sunrise and sunset. Easy walk to the pier, beach, and the small convenience store.
Also, the McCormack Management is very professional and friendly. I wouldn't hesitate to stay at the cottage again or another one of their properties. They provided all the incidentals you might forget to pack, which is very helpful.
Hope to stay in Cedar Key again soon.
I think anybody would enjoy their stay at the cottage.