Overall we really enjoyed our stay at Con Alma. Nothing about the home is super fancy and some of if was obviously DIYed, but the location was exactly what I was looking for - quiet with mountain views and not totally isolated. There are several nearby homes that didn't appear in the listing photos, but they weren't distracting at all. The wood burning stove was nice and plenty of wood was provided, the showers were hot, and while the WiFi is definitely not great the TV package does include lots of movie channels. Don't plan on cooking any complicated or fancy meals - the random cookware available seemed to have been scavenged from a yard sale and has absolutely seen better days.
It was super easy to get to the house even with several inches of snow in just a small AWD vehicle. However, exploring further down some of the county roads (anything with a CR-#) to get to nearby hiking trails you'd definitely want 4WD with good clearance. These roads seem to quickly turn into something closer to off-road tracks as they gain elevation.
TLDR: If you want a quiet, simple mountain getaway that's still within an easy drive of Fairplay, this is a nice spot. If you're looking for luxury or planning to work remotely, this is not the house for you.