My wife and I stayed at Capo La Gala as part of our honeymoon, and it was the best hotel stay of our life. The amenities of the hotel were amazing, including the restaurant, pool, direct sea access, and the MOST incredible views from a gym that you will ever experience.
The cuisine at the restaurant deserves special mention, as it was absolutely fantastic. We had breakfast, lunch, evening cocktails, and dinner at each of the dining options, and we loved the 6-course meal (the chef's choice option) at the Maxi restaurant.
My wife and I have been to well-over 30 countries, and this was also the most professional, courteous, and personable staff we have ever encountered. The individuals as a collective group set the gold standard of what a 5-star location should aim to achieve.
Finally, we loved the Vico Equense area. The town itself was cute, with great views and restaurants and a more quiet nature in contrast to the overcrowded nature of the rest of the Amalfi Coast. However, the hotel does offer a complementary on-demand shuttle to the Vico Equense train station (about a 4 minute ride), which is then connected to Sorrento by a 15 minute train ride. From Sorrento, you can access the remainder of the coast quiet easily.
The hotel also helped us arrange a day-trip boat excursion to Capri. The cost was 149 Euro per person, and while Capri was rather hectic and somewhat of a disappointment, the hours on the semi-private boat were breathtaking and well-worth the experience.