Per my teenage daughter - this place deserves an 11 out of 10.
I was nervous based on some of the reviews. It seems like people loved it or hated it. Here is what I think about the negative issues:
Directions: you will he told to call Randy for instructions. He will tell you the lockbox number and how to find the house. Listen to him! You won’t find it just with google maps. The people complaining about not know how to find it/ get in, must not have called him.
Driveway: it is very steep, but definitely doable, even in our rented hybrid sedan. However, I would not want to do it in the dark, especially the first time. Make sure you arrive before sunset. The point of this place is the view of the river, so you should be there in daylight anyway.
Decor: yes, it is dated, but well kept and very clean. Kitchen was well stocked, and isn’t that more important than granite countertops?
Doors between bedrooms: this a one bedroom plus loft without a soundproof door between the beds. Probably would be awkward for two couples who want their space, but great for a family with kids.
Bottom line: we would definitely stay here again. Comfy beds, nice deck, decent WiFi.