Pros:
1. Owner was very responsive, and gave us lots of info on shopping and eating and anything we asked.
2. House really has the lovely views that you see in the pictures and the house was very clean and brand new.
3. Lots of plates/bowls/glass cups for many people, with a dishwasher too.
4. Not far from ferry to Nantucket or easy ride to the bike path.
Cons:
1. Layout didn't work for our family, one bedroom is off by itself, without a view, so noone wanted to stay there. So, five of us shared one shower/sink for getting ready. "Annex" as we called it would be good for some families, just not really ours.
2. The house was very bare. No clocks that we noticed, no rugs, no mirror other than for our face, nothing extra in the kitchen, i.e. no spices, no foils/wraps, minimal serving/mixing bowls, we had to buy everything that you could possibly use. There were coffee filters.
3. Biggest bummer to me was the beach, it was as advertised, I just didn't get it. You are on a Nantucket Sound beach, you can only walk a little in both directions, and you constantly have to walk around the jettys. You have to drive to a walking beach.
It really was lovely, I appreciated the cleanliness of everything, it just probably wasn't the ideal house for my family.